Mike Buckley argues that the UK may have the freedom Brexiters promised, but no idea what is in its best economic interests
Read Part One of Mike Buckley’s analysis below
The dual impact of Coronavirus and Brexit would matter less if the UK was in an economically strong position. In reality, 2010-2020 was the worst decade for the UK economy for generations.
GDP growth averaged 2.5% in the 2000s but fell to 1.1% in the 2010s. Output per hour was 18% below the average for the rest of the G7 – the largest seven economies in the world. Wages fell by 10% in real terms in the eight years to 2016; yet elsewhere in the OECD – an economic alliance of 37 nations – wages grew by an average of 6.7%.
The current account deficit – the difference between Britain’s imports and exports with the rest of the world – hit £96.2 billion or 5.2% of GDP in 2015, the widest since records began in 1948.
The UK relies on foreign investors to plug the shortfall. We do not yet know what proportion of this inward investment was dependent on the country’s presence in the EU, combined with free movement and the attractiveness of an English-speaking capital with its financial, political and business hubs concentrated in a single city – but we are certainly about to find out.
We do know that the Brexit vote has impacted the economy – exclusively in a negative way. By mid-2019, foreign investment had fallen to its lowest level in six years, suggesting that uncertainty over the UK’s future trading arrangements with the EU and the rest of the world was holding back investment. And this trend wasn’t common across the EU. A fall in foreign investment to the UK was matched by an increase in the 27 member states of the EU.
SUBSCRIBE TO BYLINE TIMES FOR AS LITTLE AS £29 A YEAR
Reduced investment has in turn impacted the jobs market, with a 29% decrease in jobs created in the year ending in March, compared with the previous year. As ever, poorer regions fared worst. While London saw a 14% drop in jobs created, in Yorkshire and the Humber job creation more than halved in the year ending March 2019.
An Aging Nation
Adding to its challenges, the UK faces several structural problems that will make staging a recovery even harder.
Britain’s aging population will begin to have serious economic effects over the next decade. By 2039, there will be six million more pensioners in Britain than in 2016; comprising 23% of the population. This will add between 1% and 2% to national health costs every year, not factoring in lower wages or the increased costs of new drugs. The next 20 years will require dramatic increases in NHS and social care spending.
As the Government ends free movement and heavily restricts immigration, this will merely compound the problem – reducing the number of working-age people able to pay for this health spending. In turn, the UK will also lose skills and talent – indeed the loss of academics to other countries has already begun.
Brexit and Levelling Up
Observer journalist William Keegan recently wrote that if Johnson “goes on in the direction he and his frightful lieutenant Dominic Cummings are heading, he will go down as having run the most disastrous government most of us can remember. Moreover, he will be forgiven by neither this generation nor the next”.
Keegan adds that “no-deal Brexit and Johnson’s ‘FDR’ ambitions are irreconcilable” – referring to Johnson’s grandiose claims that he will mimic former US President Franklin Roosevelt and invest his way out of the crisis to prevent a jobs catastrophe. It is a pledge hardly backed up by policy announcements thus far.
Keegan is right. Levelling up and preventing a jobs catastrophe are incompatible with a ‘no deal’ Brexit or the thin, almost meaningless, deal that is the alternative given Johnson’s red lines. But here the economics and politics collide.
Johnson and the Conservatives are convinced that victory in 2024 depends on being able to say that they “got Brexit done” and that it was the real thing – not a halfway house that would leave the UK subject to EU law or regulations.
As former Conservative Cabinet Minister David Gauke wrote recently, the “nature of the coalition of support created in 2019 on the basis of ‘getting Brexit done’ and successfully capturing large numbers of northern and midland low-income Labour voters means that a return to a traditional, liberal, middle-class Conservatism would doom dozens of newly elected MPs”.
Johnson will not take that chance, though his belief that ‘Red Wall’ voters all supported him on the basis of getting Brexit done is misplaced. For many voters, his pledges on the NHS and police were far more consequential – pledges they will judge him harshly for, if he fails to deliver.
Learning from Past Failures
Chancellor Rishi Sunak must not make the same mistakes as his predecessors. National debt and the de

