Outside the system

‘America Is Ignoring the Warning Signs of Giving Up Its Commitment to Fighting Human Rights Abuses – At Home and Abroad’

The Trump administration appears concerned that it would be hypocritical to criticise governments abroad for doing things which it would like to do in the US, writes Washington-based Alexandra Hall Hall

US President Donald Trump signs an executive order during his second term in office. Photo: PA/Alamy

Read Our Monthly Magazine

And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system

Every year, the McCain Institute – established to continue the legacy of character-driven leadership by the late Republican Senator John McCain – honours an attendee at its annual Sedona Forum with its ‘Courage and Leadership’ Award.

Previous recipients have included Pakistani women’s education activist Malala Yousafzai; Syria’s White Helmets; Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky; the women of Iran; and last year, posthumously, Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny, who was murdered in a Russian prison for daring to speak out against Vladimir Putin.

This year, the award went to Maria Corina Machado, leader of Venezuela’s democratic movement, who has been in hiding for more than nine months, since last year’s presidential elections, which the ruling regime of Nicolas Maduro refused to recognise as being won by her candidate. Instead, it instituted a further crackdown on Venezuela’s opposition.

Accepting the award on her behalf, her daughter Ana Corina Sosa Machado said that her mother was fighting not just for today, but for the freedom of “future generations to come”, and that freedom fighters everywhere – whether in Russia, Ukraine, Africa, or other parts of Latin America – were all fighting for the same cause.

“Everywhere, the fight for freedom is one and the same,” she said.

Earlier in the conference, participants heard from Anaise Kanimba, a survivor of the 1994 Rwandan genocide, during which her father, Paul Rusesabagina – the real-life hero of the film Hotel Rwanda – saved more than 1,200 people. Kanimba led an international campaign to secure the release of her father after he was detained illegally in Rwanda in 2020 and has since become an advocate for human rights defenders everywhere.

‘Lady Chatterley’s Brexit’

Not accepting or being able to discuss the damage caused by Britain’s exit from the EU leaves the country in a unsustainable position, writes Chris Grey

We also heard from Roya Mahboob, a female Afghan entrepreneur, who helped establish the first Afghan women’s robotics team, and is continuing efforts to support Afghan women’s education from outside the country, following the Taliban’s takeover in August 2021.    

Other attendees included Svetlana Tsikhanouskaya, leader of Belarus’s pro-democracy movement, who entered politics after her husband was arrested, and was later forced into exile. Her husband remains in jail, his condition unknown. She was joined by Vladimir Kara-Murza, the Russian political activist who was sentenced to 25 years in a Siberian gulag for his opposition to Russia’s war in Ukraine, and released last summer, as part of the largest prisoner exchange with Russia since the end of the Cold War. Also in attendance was Aisu Kurmasheva, a Russian-American journalist with Radio Free Europe, who was freed from a Russian prison at the same time as Kara-Murza, in the same prisoner exchange.   

Every year, the testimonials of courageous individuals such as these, or their family members, have formed the emotional highlight of the annual Sedona Forum. It was impossible not to feel anguish as Dasha Navalnya received the award on behalf of her deceased father last year. For two years in a row, Vladimir Kara-Murza’s wife, Evgenia, attended the Sedona Forum alone, to raise awareness not just of her husband’s plight, but that of thousands of other political prisoners in Russia. As American Ambassador Roger Carstens, who coordinated the prisoner exchange leading to Kara Murza’s release, said at the conference, it was the highlight of his year to see Vladimir and Evgenia finally reunited and able to enjoy a cocktail together.

This year, in the context of Trump’s ‘America First’ philosophy, and radical cuts to US aid programmes, all of these participants were at pains to stress the continuing need for American leadership in the world, noting that when the US withdrew, the world became more dangerous.

Svetlana Tsikhanouskaya urged the US not to agree to an unjust peace deal in Ukraine, warning: “We need the USA to stay consistent and principled. Don’t allow the sphere of influence which Putin wants, and don’t abandon Belarus. The US has always been a beacon for freedom and in the fight against dictatorships.”

Kara Murza urged that any peace deal should not just be about land and minerals, but about people, including the thousands of Ukrainian children kidnapped by Russia, Ukrainian prisoners of war, and Russian political prisoners unjustly imprisoned for speaking out against the invasion.

Anaise Kanimba made a similar point regarding peace efforts in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, urging that this be based on real political change and address root causes, including Rwanda’s role in fuelling the conflict for profit. She excoriated western countries, including the UK, for taking at face value Rwanda’s claims to be a champion in the developing world and potential partner on refugee or peacekeeping matters.