Free from fear or favour
No tracking. No cookies

The Heartbreaking Stories of Life in Britain for Victims of No-Fault Evictions – Five Years After They Were Meant to be Outlawed

Despite the Conservatives pledging to get rid of no-fault evictions in 2019 landlords are using it in record numbers with a 28% increase in 2023

No-fault eviction notices served in England increased by almost a third in 2023, with 30,230 landlords launching court proceedings against their tenants. Photo: PA Images / Alamy

Newsletter offer

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive editorial emails from the Byline Times Team.

Sulejman Kamara has been trapped in a hotel for two years. The builder, his wife and two autistic children lost their home of eight years in Kilburn, north-west London, after their landlord served them a no-fault eviction. 

They never got back their deposit, and lost several possessions in the eventual bailiff-enforced eviction in 2022.

“It was shocking to have to leave like that with our two kids,” he told Byline Times. “Imagine having to leave so suddenly with a one year old.”

They were also left homeless as local estate agents refused to show them family homes because they did not meet financial requirements, which Sulejman says included having an external guarantor and being able to pay several months rent upfront.

After asking Brent Council for help, the family were moved to a nearby hotel where they shared one mould-ridden room. That was supposed to last just a few weeks as it is unlawful for councils to accommodate families in temporary accommodation that is a privately-owned B&B for more than 6 weeks. But, two year later the family is still living in that same, single, room and things have got worse.

Campaigners from the charity Shelter lined Parliament Square with boxes of household items while calling on the government to deliver a Renters Reform Bill that gets rid of Section 21 'no-fault' eviction
Campaigners from the charity Shelter line Parliament Square with boxes of household items while calling on the government to end ‘no-fault’ eviction in July 2023. Photo: Zuma Press / Alamy

The council stopped giving the family housing duty a year ago after they rejected a permanent property it offered that their doctor and school said was unsafe for their children. The council classed the family as making themselves ‘intentionally homeless’, a council-determined category that strips people of access to support. It means someone is homeless because of something they did, or failed to do.

Sulejman and his wife now pay £1,500 a month for a room, are unable to get a new home from the council and can’t access the private rental market, despite both working. Brent Council told Byline Times it can’t “reopen the housing duty” to the family.

The family is just one of almost 105,000 households living in temporary accommodation in the UK and struggling to get out of it, and one of thousands of victims of no-fault evictions. In March, The Guardian reported that some children are now spending their entire childhoods in temporary accommodation and that thousands of families had been housed in it for more than a decade. The publication said the homelessness crisis is “spiralling out of control”.

Last week marks five years since the Conservative Government first pledged to outlaw the practice. On March 1, London Mayor Sadiq Khan demanded the Government finally act on its promise to protect renters as City Hall analysis found that more than 30,000 renting households in the capital have faced a Section 21 ‘no-fault eviction’ claim since 2019.

‘Trapped’: Tenants Consider ‘Rent Strikes’ in Response to Sky-Rocketing Service Fees

The first quarter of 2024 has seen a fourfold increase in tenants investigating how to notify landlords of their intention to strike

But despite a formal Renters (Reform) Bill finally entering Parliament in May 2023 pledging to end no-fault evictions, extensive lobbying by landlords and Conservative MPs has seen it heavily watered down, and the proposed ban on no-fault evictions at best being delayed, potentially indefinitely.

In the meantime, the number of no-fault eviction notices served in England increased by almost a third (28%) in 2023, the highest rate since 2016 – 30,230 landlords started court proceedings against their tenants.

Byline Times spoke to those forced out through the practice to gauge what the impact of the delay would have.

Nico had lived in the same Brighton flat for eight years before their landlord told them they had to move out. They planned to sell the building to a new owner, and last month Nico received a notice ordering them to leave. 

Blood, Faeces, Rubbish, Mice: The Student Accommodation Crisis Laid Bare

Student housing has never been known for its quality but, in recent years, the system has been pushed to breaking point

“I’m disabled and don’t work so I’m reliant on benefits system, which obviously is difficult enough in itself. But almost impossible when it comes to trying to find somewhere to live,” they told Byline Times.

“And I’ve never actually been in this situation before when I haven’t been working.”

Research in 2022 by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism of tens of thousands of rental properties, found 98% of those advertised over a single month were beyond the means of people received universal credit or housing benefit. Analysis by the Financial Times suggested that the last time house prices were this expensive relative to incomes was in the 1870s. The average house price in the 12 months to January 2024 in England was £299,000, according to Government figures.  The average salary, across all industry sectors in the UK, was £34,900 pre-tax, according to figures published in March.

Nico’s landlord has been talking about the eviction for months, but has not given any firm timeline as to when they need to leave by, leaving them “in a constant state of stress and anxiety”.

“To not know – it makes you feel insecure and vulnerable,” Nico said. 

EXCLUSIVE

‘They Can’t Complain or They will Be on the Street’: Delay in Renters Reform Bill Puts Tenants in Peril of Mould, Damp and Dangerous Disrepair

Conservative backbenchers, many of whom are landlords, are trying to abolish schemes which reveal much higher rates of disrepair

“The possibility of becoming homeless is very real, and it’s terrifying one. I’ve been homeless before many years ago and it was horrible. My health right now is very different to what it used to be then and I wouldn’t be able to cope with it now.

“It feels like you’re in a bog and can’t quite get out. It’s suffocating, and it’s terrifying,” they add.

Journalist Ruby Lott-Lavigna has covered the housing crisis for the likes of openDemocracy and Vice, so stories like Nico’s are all too familiar. But she’s also has first-hand experience, having been served a no-fault eviction notice in February – her second in two years.

“It’s bonkers when your own reporting suddenly becomes your life,” she told Byline Times

“Being constantly evicted, or constantly at risk of eviction, leaves you in this permanent state of insecurity. It means I can’t put roots down wherever I live. 

“It means I can’t build that relationship with the local cafe that I was going to, or no longer contribute to the community garden that I wanted to get involved in. It creates this permanent instability in a societal sense. It also is just emotionally very uprooting.

“You can’t think about trying out a new career, or even dating someone new. So many of those decisions are so tied to your housing that you’re stuck in a way.”

What made Ruby’s latest eviction all the worse is that it was done, she claims, in retaliation, after she pushed back against constant, often unaccounted visits from her landlord or people working for them.

ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE

Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.

We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.

Most tenants have a legal right to “quiet enjoyment” of their home which entitles them to be left alone by the landlord or those working for them unless necessary – and even then they should give a day’s warning before visiting.

But as the name suggests, a no-fault eviction means a landlord doesn’t have to give a reason to evict a tenant. It also means they can, and frequently do, use the power to evict tenants for making complaints about them failing to make repairs and breaking the law.

A report by Citizens Advice in 2018 found that renters in England who formally complain about issues such as damp and mould have an almost one-in-two (46%) chance of being issued an eviction notice within six months.

“It’s infuriating that something as petty as this can result in a complete change of mine and my housemates’ lives,” Ruby said. “It’s even more maddening that this was legislation that was promised to be banned five years ago.”

She continued: “The Conservatives for too long have played politics like it’s a game, not peoples’ lives. And that is exactly what you see with the Renter’s Reform Bill, because every day more people get made redundant, or like me are gonna get evicted.”


Written by

This article was filed under
,