While the Labour Party are mired in allegations of anti-Semitism, Henry Dyer reports on how Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party seems to be faring no better

Share this article

The Conservative Party is “unserious about the three anti-Semitism investigations” it announced into candidates who stood during the 2019 General Election campaign, the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism has said. 

On 7 December 2019, The Guardian reported that the party had launched inquiries into Sally-Ann Hart, the candidate who would be elected MP for Hastings; Lee Anderson, the candidate who would be elected MP for Ashfield; and Richard Short, the ultimately unsuccessful candidate for St Helens South and Whiston.

Within a week of the initial announcement of these investigations into alleged anti-Semitism, the Conservative Party announced it had expanded the investigation into Hart to include an inquiry into alleged Islamophobia. 

None of the candidates were suspended pending the outcome of the investigations.

During the election campaign, Prime Minister Boris Johnson apologised for the “hurt and offence” caused by Islamophobia within the party and issued a hardline approach, saying that “obviously whenever we have an incident of anti-Semitism or Islamophobia or whatever in the Conservative Party, we take a zero-tolerance approach…. We have a ‘one bounce and we deal with it’ approach to this”.

But after more than eight months later, the party is yet to formally announce the outcome of any of its investigations.

The Allegations

The initial investigation into Sally-Ann Hart came after the successor to the former Home Secretary Amber Rudd’s constituency shared a video with an image that implied that George Soros, the Jewish billionaire philanthropist, controlled the EU. Hart also ‘liked’ a comment under the video saying “Ein Reich” – a Nazi slogan.

The investigation into Lee Anderson began after it emerged that he was an active member of a Facebook group called ‘Ashfield Backs Boris’, on which conspiracy theories about Soros were promoted.

An inquiry into Richard Short started after it was revealed that, posting on Twitter in 2013, he had questioned the “allegiance” of journalist Melanie Phillips to the UK, agreeing with another Twitter user that “her allegiance is greater to Israel”. He added: “She almost has to declare an interest.” Short apologised for his comments, which the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism described as anti-Semitic slurs, calling for the party to take immediate action.

Earlier this month, in an interview with Channel 4 News‘ Krishnan Guru-Murthy, Hart suggested that the investigation into the allegations against her had been concluded.

“Those posts – the accusations were made in the last week of an election campaign – a panel hearing has been heard,” she said. “I’ve attended social media training. And I’ve not been found to be anti-Semitic, Islamophobic, or anything else.”

When asked if the posts were a mistake, Hart said: “They were posts that I did three years ago. And I’m not here to answer those questions. I was asked to answer questions on illegal immigration. So I’m not answering anymore. I’ve answered your question.”

Byline Times understands that the inquiry into Short is still ongoing and, although an investigation into Anderson has apparently concluded, the report has yet to be made available. The report into the allegations against Hart has also not been released.


Commenting on the failure of the party to announce the conclusion and outcome of the investigations, a spokesperson for the Campaign Against Anti-Semitism told Byline Times that “it is becoming clear that the party is unserious” about them.

“These were investigations that the party reassuringly announced at the end of last year, in some cases before the allegations were even known to the public,” they said. “But there is no justification for these investigations to have taken eight months with still no end in sight… by delaying for so long the party risks making its poor procedures, rather than the allegations themselves, the real story”.

The Jewish Chronicle reported last month that the Board of Deputies – the oldest communal Jewish organisation in the UK – would be meeting Conservative Party chairman Amanda Milling MP at the end of July.

The outcome of that meeting is unknown, but it followed an earlier meeting, reported in the Jewish Chronicle, held in April between the Board of Deputies and the Conservative Party, in which the board discussed issues “including claims of anti-Semitism against some of the party’s MPs”.

Conservatives often criticise the Labour Party for allegations of anti-Semitism within its ranks. It seems that Boris Johnson’s party similarly needs to get its house in order, on this front.

Byline Times approached the Conservatives, Sally-Ann Hart and Lee Anderson for comment, but they had not responded at the time of publication.


Byline Times is funded by its subscribers. Receive our monthly print edition and help to support fearless, independent journalism.

New to Byline Times? Find out more about us


A new type of newspaper – independent, fearless, outside the system. Fund a better media.

Don’t miss a story! Sign up to our newsletter (and get a free edition posted to you)

Our leading investigations include: empire & the culture warBrexit, crony contractsRussian interferencethe Coronavirus pandemicdemocracy in danger, and the crisis in British journalism. We also introduce new voices of colour in Our Lives Matter.

More stories filed under Fact

Why It’s Important Boris Johnson Hands Over WhatsApp Messages to the COVID-19 Inquiry

, 26 May 2023
Lawyer Gareth Roberts explains how theDame Hallet's inquiry has the full force of the law and is not a constitutional nicety the former Prime Minister can wriggle out of

EXCLUSIVE Female Met Police Officer Cleared of Domestic Abuse Allegations After Three-Year Probe Triggered by ‘Controlling’ Senior Police Ex

, 25 May 2023
An extraordinary Met Police disciplinary hearing concludes with a female officer being exonerated from abuse claims from her former partner, a more senior cop himself facing abuse claims

EXCLUSIVE Thousands in England Denied a Vote as Exclusive Snapshot of Photo ID Rollout Revealed

, 24 May 2023
Over 6,000 voters were turned away and didn't return across around 50 council areas, Byline Times can reveal.

More from the Byline Family