Rupert Read and Tara Greaves on recent ONS figures that prove the much-hyped Oxford Model based on Coronavirus immunity was based on false premises
Facts are stubborn things, but statistics are pliable.
Mark Twain
While toilet rolls, pasta and flour may have been hard to come by during the Coronavirus crisis, there has never been a shortage of statistics.
The Government’s unreliable stats on personal protective equipment (counting two gloves as two items of PPE, for instance), on tests (counting tests sent out and multiple tests on the same person towards its 100,000 a day target, which has probably not once yet been achieved), and on deaths (failing, for instance, to include excess deaths) are legion.
But one set of stats was particularly dangerous. They were widely used in certain quarters to try to suggest that the Government’s policy – explicit for a while, and since then, after outcry, implicit – of ‘herd immunity’ might be on the right track.
‘Herd immunity’ refers to the state whereby enough members of a population have acquired immunity to a disease so that it cannot spread within that group – suggested to be between 60-80% for COVID-19 or about 40-50 million people in the UK.
Neither peer-reviewed nor published in any scientific journal but released via a PR agency, a study from Oxford University’s Evolutionary Ecology of Infectious Disease Group spawned a raft of headlines in March declaring that as much as half of the UK population had already been infected with the Coronavirus. It also led to some speculation that physical distancing measures introduced a few days prior could be unnecessary.
However, a new report by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) reveals that, as was strongly suspected at the time, the Oxford study was way off. Its figures were far from true — in fact, antibody tests conducted on a random sample of households suggest that fewer than 7% of people in England have been infected with the virus.
This in turn suggests that the draft Oxford survey should probably have never have been in the public domain because, had it been relied upon, the death toll in this country – while horrific enough – would have been much greater.
So why was the study released? And why did the Government delay taking any precautionary action for so long, despite substantial evidence in favour of this even from its own advisors?
In six words: to try to boost the economy.
The Roots of ‘Herd Immunity’
For circumstantial evidence to support that general hypothesis, one only needs to look at the timeline of delays – delays that experts believe cost “tens of thousands of lives”.
For much of March, the Government resolutely stuck to the ‘delay and contain’ phases of managing the crisis, despite strong warnings from its two main modelling teams that this could lead to a “catastrophic number of people being killed”.
The Prime Minister first publically floated the idea of ‘herd immunity’ on 5 March on ITV’s This Morning. When asked whether delaying the Coronavirus was about ‘flattening the curve’ of the pandemic, he said: “That’s where a lot of debate has been and one of the theories is that perhaps you could take it on the chin, take it all in one go and allow the disease, as it were, to move through the population, without taking as many draconian measures.”
But, even before this, the Prime Minister had already laid the groundwork for the idea much earlier, in a

