Outside the system

The Deepfake Election: How Disinformation Could Swing the 2029 General Election

The next UK General Election could see the perfect storm for political lying, the head of factchecking organisation Full Fact tells Byline Times

Full Fact CEO Chris Morris previously set up and led the BBC's Reality Check team

Read Our Monthly Magazine

And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system

“A lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its shoes.” So the old adage goes, one which rings truer than ever in the age of social media misinformation. 

The quote is often attributed to Mark Twain. And Winston Churchill. And Thomas Jefferson. Fitting then, that it wasn’t any of them, but most likely the satirist Jonathan Swift. 

The problem it highlights, however, is the bread and butter of UK-based fact-checking organisation Full Fact. And their workload is only increasing now that generative artificial intelligence tools are making misinformation easier to create on a mass scale than ever before. 

“We’re at a critical moment,” the non-profit group’s CEO Chris Morris tells me. “We’re only 15 years into what is probably a 100-year information revolution, and goodness knows where it’s going to end up.” 

And it coincides with the apparent decline of traditional broadcasters’ status – like the BBC’s – as a single, hegemonic source of trustworthy information. That has risks and opportunities.

Don’t miss a story

“It’s good that we’re not in an era of deferential news, where the BBC or others handed down truth like tablets from the mountain. We don’t want that – skepticism is good. The trouble is the pendulum has swung to the other extreme, where you’ve got a million narratives on social media,” Morris says. 

Nor are the public taking politicians’ words at face value. Trust in politicians has hit crisis levels, with only 18% of the public having “at least a fair amount” of trust in the ability of MPs to tell the truth, compared to three-quarters (76%) of Britons who doubt their honesty, according to YouGov research this September. 

The latest Ipsos Mori Veracity Index also shows politicians remain at the bottom of the pile – only 11% of people in the UK believe they can trust politicians to tell the truth, up from last year’s worst-ever 9%. 

Morris describes the very clear findings as “appalling”. In a wide-ranging interview with Byline Times, the former BBC journalist argues we are merely “15 years into what is probably a 100-year information revolution,” with major implications for truth and democracy. 

And while predictions that artificial intelligence would destroy the credibility of our elections 2024 haven’t materialised in the UK, that’s not the case elsewhere. 

Morris points to Romania and the Russian influence exerted online, which caused the Constitutional Court to annul their latest presidential election this month. In Moldova, TikTok was ‘flooded with anti-Europe disinformation before the EU referendum on 20 October’ Moldovan journalist Paula Erizanu noted. Election officials are fighting back. But it could be a taste of what is to come. Did the UK have a lucky escape this July? 

“The threat is real. One reason it didn’t happen much in the UK is that if you’re running a bot farm in St Petersburg, when parties said [a few] weeks before the election ‘we know we’ve lost’, there’s not much point in interfering,” Morris says. 

The “jury is still out” on how much mis- and disinformation influenced the recent US election, he adds. “Their electoral system’s vulnerabilities, where it comes down to tens of thousands of people in various states, make it ripe for potential foul play.” The UK’s first-past-the-vote electoral system also, by this reasoning, makes election meddling through fake news particularly appealing if it can be targeted to a handful of highly-significant swing seats, in a future – closer – election that we saw this summer. 

UPDATE

Keir Starmer Considers Closing Elon Musk Donations Loophole to Stop ‘Foreign Interference’ in UK Elections

A rumoured $100 million donation from Musk to Nigel Farage’s Reform would be banned under the proposal

Deepfake technology – AI-generated video and audio of real people and politicians doing and saying things they have not said or done – is also rapidly advancing. “I ask my head of AI where we’ll be with technology and generative AI in three years, and he says it’s hard to tell even three or four months ahead.”

The fact-checking chief expresses particular concern about older people’s vulnerability to misinformation, arguing that education to develop critical thinking skills needs to be rapidly expanded across all age groups. 

He reveals that when Full Fact conducted focus groups on misinformation last summer, it wasn’t election misinformation that came out as a top concern – but financial scams targeting elderly relatives.  

Morris also criticises the UK’s new Online Safety Act for leaving Ofcom largely powerless to tackle the vast majority of misinformation, which falls into the category of “legal but harmful” content. Conservative politicians scuppered efforts for the bill to cover a wider range of misinformation when it was going through Parliament in 2023. 

Despite that, Morris argues that elected politicians are better suited to regulating online disinformation, rather than “executives in California or Beijing” who run the vast tech firms so much of our information ecosystem relies on. 

ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE

Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.

We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.

The question of whether those politicians tell the truth though is fraught. 

“Voters can remove their MPs at elections, but Parliament should think harder about taking collective responsibility for MPs who consistently mislead people,” Morris says. 

“It’s difficult because they must decide who’s the judge and jury – could it be done through the committee system? A more transparent process of accountability, particularly for statements in the House but also on social media, might make people less cynical about politics.” 

Elite Paywalls or Social Media Misinformation: The Alarming Future of ‘Two Tier’ Journalism

“The UK’s news environment [risks] fracturing irreparably along social, regional and economic lines… The implications for our society and democracy would be grim.”