Outside the system

The Conservative Government Put Forward ‘Crappy’ Laws, Say Conservative Politicians

The last Government passed shabbily-drafted pieces of legislation which were only saved by amendments from Labour and the House of Lords, according to two senior Conservative figures

Legislation passed by MPs to send asylum seekers to Rwanda was in a "ridiculous" state, along with many other "really crappy worded, poorly drafted bits of legislation"

Read Our Monthly Magazine

And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system

Two Conservative figures have admitted that their Government tried to push through multiple pieces of legislation that were in a “crappy” and “ridiculous” state – in the expectation that the unelected House of Lords would fix them through amendments.  

At a Westminster event on House of Lords reform, hosted by the liberal conservative think tank Bright Blue, two Conservative politicians praised the work of the Lords in fixing legislation their own Government had proposed in the last Parliament. 

Conservative peer Lord (Shaun) Bailey, who is also an elected London Assembly member, was in the audience and raised objections to making the House of Lords an elected chamber, partly due to their role in tidying up Rishi Sunak’s controversial legislation to deport unsuccessful asylum seekers to Rwanda.. 

After reeling out several arguments against Lords reform, he said: “All of those issues I think need answering before we then get rid of [the Lords], because I’m sure that we need a chamber to balance the Commons.

“I’ll give it to you like this: Rwanda. The Rwanda legislation… I voted for it, and I was always going to vote for it. But it was ridiculous, the state it arrived in the Lords. Ironically, Labour peers made it better. They held that idea down, and thrashed it around. 

“And I remember being more happy voting for it after Labour colleagues had beaten it up a bit, than when it first arrived. And if we lose that, we give the executive unchecked power.”

Don’t miss a story

However, if he was referring to this April’s Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Act, the Lords were unable to make substantive changes to it – because they kept being overridden by the Conservative majority in the Commons. 

According to the Institute for Government: “Although the House of Lords held out for several rounds of ping-pong, in the end the only concessions were an amendment requiring the Secretary of State to produce an annual report about the operation of the Act in relation to modern slavery and people trafficking.” 

The other half-concession from ministers was “a non-[binding] commitment…that the Government would not remove to Rwanda those deemed (after a review) eligible under the Afghan relocations and assistance policy.” 

Conservative MP Simon Hoare, a former minister in Rishi Sunak’s Government, defended the role of a second chamber, saying: “I think the quality of scrutiny in the House of Commons is getting lower and lower and lower, and that is in part because of executive power and the power of the whips…