Byline Times is an independent, reader-funded investigative newspaper, outside of the system of the established press, reporting on ‘what the papers don’t say’ – without fear or favour.
To support its work, subscribe to the monthly Byline Times print edition, packed with exclusive investigations, news, and analysis.
“We need to end what I call ‘Governmentitis’” Kemi Badenoch told her party conference this week.
Urging them to abandon “the belief that we’re going to be in Government very soon” Badenoch called on them to instead embrace the freedom and opportunity of opposition.
“I’m sad to be in opposition, but there’s a part of me that’s excited…” Badenoch told the conference during her closing speech on Wednesday.
“We are going to have fun”.
She wasn’t kidding.
Whether it was suggesting that the level of maternity pay women receive is “excessive”, attacking the minimum wage, or calling on tens of thousands of civil servants to be thrown into jail, the former Business Secretary clearly enjoyed her newfound freedom this week more than most.
She wasn’t the only one. In conference bars and meeting rooms, Conservative MPs and activists all queued up to luxuriate in the liberty of losing all power and responsibility.
At fringe meeting after meeting, panelists celebrated the new Labour government’s difficulties, while dismissing their own recent downfall as simply being the result of having “talked right but governed left”.
The luxury of this argument is that it allows the party to continue saying and doing all of the things that helped get them into opposition in the first place.
Whether its demanding massive tax cuts at a time when public services are literally falling apart, lashing out at young people at a time when the average age of a Conservative voter has risen to the mid sixties, or doubling down on the same anti-immigrant rhetoric which triggered the rise of Reform, the Conservative party seems intent on digging itself even further into its own electoral hole.
A ‘Natural’ Return to Government?
This complacency has only been helped by the political difficulties Keir Starmer’s Government has quickly got itself into.
Rachel Reeves’ decision to cut the winter fuel allowance and the subsequent Labour donations scandal have both helped to lure Conservative members into the dangerous belief that they can expect to be back in Government in just a few years time.
As defeated leadership candidate Mel Stride told one meeting, the party could now expect for voters to “naturally” return to the party over the coming months and years.
This idea has been buoyed by the belief among some Conservatives in the inherent wickedness of their opponents.
“Labour are in and everyone can see that they’re the bad guys and we’re the good guys”, Kemi Badenoch told one fringe event, before later accusing the left of “stealthily poisoning our society”.
Yet while, Labour’s ratings may have plunged since the general election, there is little sign of voters turning back to the Conservative party instead.
And despite the huge crowds of Conservative activists that gathered to cheer on their former leader Liz Truss this week, the reality is that outside the steel wire of the conference boundaries, she is still widely reviled.
Yet rather than face up to these stark realities and apologise to voters for the economic and social damage they have done to the country, the past week has shown a party still heavily stuck in denial.
And far from looking like a party poised to regain power, the Conservatives now look much more likely to head in the complete opposite direction instead.
Not everyone in the party is blind to this risk. As the former Conservative adviser Tim Montgomerie warned his colleagues “we shouldn’t assume this is the bottom. The bottom is zero.”
And as another former Conservative adviser told another fringe meeting this week, “We cannot for one second convince ourselves that we’re not loathed. We are. And we haven’t done any of the necessary steps [to turn things around]”.
Oppositionitis
Yet despite a few lone voices calling for sanity, the disease of ‘Oppositionitis’ now appears to be running rampant through the party.
Among those suffering from it is the current frontrunner for the leadership, Robert Jenrick.
Jenrick began his political career as a centre ground pro-European but has since sought to transform his image into the candidate whose politics are closest to Nigel Farage.
Boasting that the Reform leader “knows I have all the policy answers”, Jenrick repeatedly sought to mimic him in other respects too.
Insisting that Britain’s membership of the European Convention of Human Rights is now a matter of “leave or die”, Jenrick published a Fox News-style campaign video suggesting that the ECHR was forcing British special forces to murder suspected terrorists, rather than to detain them.
The shocking claim caused a massive backlash from members of the armed forces and even other Conservative MPs, who warned he was now putting British troops at risk.
Yet freed from the responsibilities of Government, Jenrick simply mimicked Farage in refusing to apologise. The temptations and joys of Oppositionitis were simply too strong.
ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE
Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.
We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.
Many of those at Conservative conference have this week sought to compare the joyous mood of their own gathering with the almost funereal mood at Labour’s conference the week before.
Yet far from being a sign of their respective political fortunes, the differing mood is merely a sign of where power now lies, and where it does not.
If the Labour party looks depressed it’s because they have been quickly hit by the harsh realities of Government, whereas the excitement at Conservative conference is merely a sign of how far away from power they now are.
Yet just as the Labour party convinced itself in 2010 that it would be back in office after just one term, only to remain luxuriating in opposition more than a decade later, the evidence from this week suggests that the path back to power now looks similarly long and painful for the Conservative party too.