Newsletter offer
Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive editorial emails from the Byline Times Team.
As head of the Climate Change Committee (CCC), Chris Stark is responsible for advising the Government on emission targets and reporting to Parliament on progress made in reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
CCC’s most recent report on the progress towards the UK reaching NetZero highlighted the Government’s of a lack of urgency in reducing emissions and classified confidence in it meeting its 2030 reduction in GHG targets as “low”.
Last month, Stark accused the Government of sending the wrong message to consumers and the world by backing off on its commitment to net zero following Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s announcement that he was delaying the ban of sales of new diesel and petrol cars from 2030 to 2035 and 20% of households would be exempt from a new gas boiler ban.
The United Nations Climate Change Conference is an annual event where global leaders, climate change experts, charities and representatives from local communities meet to discuss and agree on solutions to tackle climate change. However, COPs in the past have been criticised for allowing fossil fuel lobbyists to join the talks. Last year Global Witness reported that there were twice as many fossil fuel lobbyists as delegates from the official UN constituency for indigenous peoples attending COP27.
Rishi Sunak attended this year’s conference, COP28, held in Dubai from 30 November to 12 December, for just half a day, reportedly spending more time in his private jet travelling to and from the event than he did in discussions. Labour leader Keir Starmer was in Dubai for three days.
Byline Times spoke to Stark on day six of the conference.
What do you hope COP28 will achieve?
Well, we have a COP every year. And here we are in Dubai. You can get overoptimistic about COPs but I’m a realist. Every COP is about moving on a little bit.
I think we’ve already achieved a lot of the things I hoped for in this COP. Notably the Loss and Damage Fund, which has now got money in it, acknowledging the fact that there has been loss and damage in parts of the world that haven’t caused the problem of climate change. That’s a big win.
I think it’s easy to forget how much progress has been made in loss and damage in the last couple of years. This was a thing that was difficult to discuss at all before Glasgow and COP26. And we are now at the point where not only have we acknowledged the problem, we’ve actually got money going into a fund, including from Scotland and the UK.
I think that these are important moments. But of course, the sums involved don’t even touch the side and we probably do need to get into a bigger discussion about what we’re doing with climate finance and how we wrap together some of the various streams. Not just with separate pots for loss and damage, for adaptation and for reducing emissions, but actually dealing with the issue of climate change in the round. And not just through token sums, but actually driving real flows of finance which involves private finance as much as much as it does publicly funded finance.
Future COPs are going to have to really wrestle with the quantum of that, which is nowhere near the sums that we’ve talked about so far.
The next thing for me is whether we get landed now some global agreements on growing renewables, improving energy efficiency and this crucial language around fossil fuel phase out or phase down. Whether we see that in a final text after this COP. I think that’s a really, really important thing.
But I think the main thing with the COP is that there people here meeting and doing important things. And this in another COP that has proved that it’s worth having.
Are you saying COP28 is already a success?
No, I don’t think you can say it’s a success until you know where you are at the end of it. This COP continues the tradition that we that we established in Glasgow in COP26, which is that you have national negotiations going on. It is very, very important to do that.
But alongside it, these ambition statements that come from outside of the national pledges are increasing about cementing the idea that we can be ambitious. You can think about the national targets, the national pledges, as raising the minimum, raising the floor. We need alongside that things that are about pushing out the maximum, pushing out the ceiling, doing more in certain areas.
This cop has been pretty good at landing some of those things so far. I think we need to see more on that. And this is going to be a COP that deals with fossil fuels in some shape or form. The acid test to whether it’s been a success is going to be at the end and what we say about the fossil fuel phase out.
In recent months the UK’s Conservative Government has rowed back on many of its green commitments with PM Rishi Sunak accused of abandoning the fight against climate change. How confident are you that a Labour government would do any better?
I’m very fortunate to not have to guess what’s going to happen in politics. We [CCC] are here to provide advice to the Government, whatever colour that Government is. I would say the same thing to a Labour government as I say to the present Conservative government: “You’ve got a lot to do.”
There’s a big, big delivery challenge here and it’s not going to be addressed by coming to Dubai and setting new targets or putting new numbers into play.
You’ve actually got to start delivering stuff. So I think that regardless of what happens at the next election, the story of UK leadership on climate is going to be much more about whether we actually deliver against these big targets than it is about setting new pledges. And that’s not something that Government typically has been that good at, of any colour, in the last 15 to 20 years, except in a couple of areas.
So what I would like to see from any future government is that we have a few more things to celebrate when it comes to actual delivery on the ground, things changing. Because for me, that’s the best story that we can bring to a COP. That UK leadership means actually delivering what you pledge. It’s about much more than just having the ambition in the first place.
That is the best message for places like China, India, Indonesia – those places that have weak targets but look like they’re over-delivering. We need to be the country that shows you have high ambition and that you deliver against it. And that’s not really about party politics.
QQQQ How do you think Scotland’s new First Minister, Humza Yousaf, is shaping up with regards to tackling climate change?
The last First Minister of Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, and was very, very keen on talking about climate change and raising the ambition for Scotland to tackle it.
I have to say I’m quite happy with the new First Minister and the things that he said on climate. I met him yesterday at the COP. He’s been here for a few days in Dubai and I think that’s a very good sign. But the most important thing about what Scotland is doing is that we are way off track for the targets that were set in law in Scotland.
And that means that we have to be critical of what’s happening in terms of Scottish Government policies. In particular, the pledge to reduce emissions by 75% by 2030 is a really big target for Scotland and we are not seeing the kind of policy program from the Scottish Government that will allow me to be confident that’s going to be met.
The test of whether the new First Minister is serious on climate isn’t that he’s willing to put a couple of million quid into the Loss and Damage Fund, good as that is, it’s the story of delivery at home. That’s the story of real Scottish leadership. Are we actually going to hit these targets and through what means are we going to see the policies put in place that drive the action that we need in Scotland to drive emissions down?
ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE
Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.
We’re no

