Black Friday versus ChristmasThe Great Replacement Reality
With their recurrent urban legends that ‘Christmas’ is to be cancelled, Christian Christensen notes the European right has somehow overlooked a genuine cultural invasion
Nothing winds up the European anti-immigration right quite like shop signs in foreign languages, bus drivers playing strange music, veiled women being treated as ordinary citizens or corporations recognizing holiday traditions from other countries or religions.
These seemingly benign components of modern society are pitched by critics as forces of cultural erosion: slowly but surely stripping away local cultures, practices and languages in favour of an alien, “globalised” multiculturalism. Those who do not share this view are accused of being naïve enablers of the demise of national identity and history, and of being blinded by political correctness and “wokeism” to the long-term impact of “cultural invasion.”
So, as an American living in Europe, it’s with considerable bemusement that I sit and watch country after country willingly embrace the artificial US consumer orgy holiday known as “Black Friday,” and without so much as a whimper from the political right who wet their collective national identity pants when they see so much as a shop sign in Arabic on a small side-street.
In just a few years, Black Friday has gone from an American consumer culture oddity to something plastered across European buses, billboards and websites. All in that foreign language English, of course.
FEARLESS, INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM
& INCREDIBLE VALUE
Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and support quality, investigative reporting.
Culturally speaking, Black Friday – concocted to get Americans to shop like lunatics the day after they eat like lunatics on Thanksgiving – clearly has far less to do with European countries such as Sweden (where I live) as holidays such as Ramadan, which is celebrated by a significant portion of Swedish, and European, citizens.
Actually, it has nothing to do with Europe. And, unlike cultural goods and languages from “other” parts of the world, Black Friday is just one component of an enormous US cultural tsunami of holidays, films, television programs, news, fast food restaurants, social media content, music and language flowing over and across everyday European lives.
So, where is the outrage? Where is the political and moral concern for “local cultures and language” being swamped by this foreign invasion? Because Black Friday is more than just an English-language slogan, it’s part of a spread of US consumer culture with significant impact on everything from increasing household debt to the demise of smaller local businesses unable to compete with large conglomerates leveraging Black Friday for sales.
Whenever I raise issues such as these, one of the most common responses I hear is that, yes, things like Black Friday, Halloween, Starbucks, US television programs and US films aren’t from [ENTER YOUR EUROPEAN COUNTRY HERE], but US culture is “closer” or more “proximate” to European culture than the cultures of, say, Syria or Somalia, and so they aren’t as damaging.
Now, that’s an interesting argument. Not because it makes sense, because it doesn’t.
It’s interesting because it exposes the utter bullshit (there is no better word) of the supposed concern over the erosion and death of “local culture” and “local language.” There’s nothing “local” in countries like Sweden about Black Friday. There’s nothing “local” about Starbucks. There’s nothing “local” about Seinfeld re-runs. There’s nothing “local” about the English language.
What those who defend the large-scale flood of US cultural goods in Europe by using the “cultural proximity” argument are saying – and what they will never admit to – is that they actually don’t care if local culture and language are eroded by a foreign culture…so long as it’s not eroded by the “wrong kind” of foreign culture. And, the “wrong kind” of culture means cultures springing from predominantly non-white, non-Christian nations and regions.
So, next Black Friday, spare a thought for the immigrant small business owner accused of undermining national culture because he is selling the wrong foreign food in a shop with a sign in the wrong foreign language…all while surrounded by hundreds of mega-stores plastered in ads using the right foreign words, leveraging the right foreign holiday in order to sell the right foreign products.
OUR JOURNALISM RELIES ON YOU
Byline Times is funded by its subscribers. Receive our monthly print edition and help to support fearless, independent journalism.
Thank you for reading this article
New to Byline Times? Find out more about us
SUBSCRIBE TO THE PRINT EDITION
A new type of newspaper – independent, fearless, outside the system. Fund a better media.
Don’t miss a story…
Our leading investigations include Brexit, Empire & the culture war, Russian interference, Coronavirus, cronyism and far right radicalisation. We also introduce new voices of colour in Our Lives Matter.