Today
Sun 17 January 2021

Stephen Colegrave investigates the shortlist for a prestigious healthcare whistleblowing award and finds serious shortcomings in those picked for the prize

In 2015, Sir Robert Francis published a report into the culture of open reporting in the NHS. Called the ‘Freedom to Speak Up’ review, there were high hopes when it recommended the creation of a National Guardian for NHS whistleblowers, alongside a public ‘Freedom to Speak Up’ campaign.

A series of high-profile scandals had shown the importance of whistleblowing in the preceding years, including the death of 456 patients at Gosport War Memorial Hospital, who were prescribed inappropriate drugs between 1988 and 2000. A public inquiry in 2018, the Gosport Review, proved that witness statements from whistleblowers at the time had been ignored. 

However, it is concerning that the majority of NHS trusts included in this year’s shortlist for the prestigious Health Service Journal’s (HSJ) ‘Freedom to Speak Up’ Award do not seem to be exemplars for whistleblowing.


Five Linked Deaths

According to the 2019 NHS Staff Survey, workers at three of the trusts shortlisted for the HSJ award said that they did not feel “secure raising concerns about unsafe clinical care” – compared to the overall national average of 72% of respondents who said that they did.

In the same survey, four of the shortlisted trusts also had above average scores in response to the question: “In the last 12 months how many times have you personally experienced harassment, bullying or abuse at work from other colleagues?” The shortlisted trust with the worst record, University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust, had more than a fifth of staff agreeing with this question.

Even more concerning, there are serious questions at one of the shortlisted trusts surrounding several incidents of avoidable death and its complaints systems.

Over the 2012 Christmas period, a 19-year-old girl called Averil Hart died of anorexia under the care of the Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust. It wasn’t until this Autumn that her family managed to establish the truth about what happened to her, when an inquest concluded that her death was avoidable and that “neglect” and systemic failures had contributed.

Averil’s family complained to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman – the body making the final decisions on complaints that have not been resolved by the NHS in England – which found that evidence had been destroyed and that a very poor complaints system was in place.

“The responses to Mr Hart’s requests for information were delayed and appeared evasive, and information he requested was often not provided,” the Ombudsman said. “The responses to his complaints were equally unsatisfactory, and often appeared defensive or protective of the organisation concerned.

“Some information stored in electronic format turned out to have been deleted; the decision to delete material related to a significant safety incident was ill considered and inappropriate… There were clear failings in the response to Mr Hart. The Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Trust’s handling of Mr Hart’s complaint was so poor that it was maladministration.”

Tragically, four more young women have subsequently died from eating disorders under Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust’s specialist care: Maria Jakes, Madeline Wallace, Emma Brown and Amanda Bowles. The coroner recognised that these five cases might be linked and is expected to issue an exceptional ‘Prevention of Future Deaths’ report following the inquests.

This trust certainly doesn’t seem to be a strong candidate for a HSJ ‘Freedom to Speak Up’ Award. But it appears not to be an aberration.

Last year’s winner of the HSJ ‘Freedom to Speak Up’ Award was Rotherham, Doncaster and South Humber NHS Foundation Trust – found not to have listened to staff concerns when patient Robert McNeill, 60, died at Great Oaks Hospital in Scunthorpe after being attacked by fellow patient Jamie Reed in January 2017. Staff had raised concerns about inadequate staffing levels before the killing.

Asked to comment on the shortcomings of the shortlist and last year’s winner, the National Guardian’s Office told Byline Times: “The judging process is managed by HSJ. These trusts were shortlisted by an independent panel, who judged each entry on the criteria published on the HSJ website.”

The selection of shortlisted trusts is indicative of the weakness of the Freedom to Speak Up programme and the way in which whistleblowers are treated by the NHS. Until the NHS has a more robust attitude and a system of encouraging and protecting whistleblowers, tragic scandals will inevitably continue to blight our healthcare system.


Thank youfor reading this article

New to Byline Times? Find out about us

Our leading investigations include Russian Interference, Coronavirus, Cronyism and Far Right Radicalisation. We also introduce new voices of colour in Our Lives Matter.


Support our journalists

To have an impact, our investigations need an audience.

But emails don’t pay our journalists, and nor do billionaires or intrusive ads. We’re funded by readers’ subscription fees:

Or donate to our seasonal crowdfunder to hire an additional journalist to conduct more investigations.

More stories filed under Alone & Exposed

More stories filed under Reportage