In the second of Byline Times’ new series dedicated to giving a platform to new voices of colour, Amina Shareef explains how George Floyd’s last words resonate across the world

Share this article

Syria speaks. It speaks to America through the street art of a now ubiquitous image – that of George Floyd and a now iconic hashtag “I can’t breathe”. But, more importantly, it speaks through the placement of this tribute: the remains of a wall once supporting perhaps a school, a nursery or a hospital, a lone shard of a wall in a sea of rubble, a wall that bears testimony to an imperial brutality that destroys life with impunity.

This image on the last standing wall of a Syrian street exposes the transnational significance and symbolism of “I can’t breathe”.

This image prods us into acknowledging that “I can’t breathe” captures more than just the cry of anguish, suppressed too long and now released by a people brutally enslaved, exploited and expelled into the rotten margins and dead-end ghettos of modern American life. 

This image narrates a story of displacement, dehumanisation, and immiseration of a planetary dimension, enduring through and created anew by historical and modern forms of imperialism and colonialisation. 

This image gives “I can’t breathe” its global substance.

“I can’t breathe” is a Muslim woman gagging on a headscarf dragged off her head, a headscarf as a noose around her neck.

“I can’t breathe” is the hooded detainee, illegally extradited, smothered by the darkness of his hood as his body is captured and transferred into sites of torture and lawlessness.

“I can’t breathe” is an Islamic intellectual, silenced by the accusations of rape, taken as political prisoner to politically suffocate a Muslim spiritual revival.

“I can’t breathe” are the floating bodies whose lungs carry the waters of the Mediterranean, bodies naturally fleeing the armed conflicts and economic famines of our manufacture.

“I can’t breathe” is the ‘terror’ suspect, repeatedly waterboarded in black sites and illegal prisons across the world in accordance with CIA interrogation manuals, only to be released as innocent of any charges.

“I can’t breathe” is the asylum seeker, crammed and stacked into overcrowded detention centres, hopefully waiting, waiting for a verdict.

“I can’t breathe” is the political dissident, closed in by the crushing loneliness of solitary confinement.

“I can’t breathe” are the gassed Syrian children, their bodies heaving as truncated life ebbs away.

“I can’t breathe” is the woman in labour pains, giving birth in a refugee camp, made stateless for being so naïve as to allow herself to be groomed by ISIS.

“I can’t breathe” is a symbol. It is a symbol of a type of life that can be cut-off from oxygen, a type of life that can be cut-off from bodies, a type of life living in brown, black, Muslim, dissenting, refuge-seeking bodies that are worth nothing.

Worth nothing because those bodies are not really human. Not really human, they can be gagged, hooded, silenced, dispossessed, drowned, tortured, detained, gassed, and denationalised into the spaces of death.

By spaces of death, I do not only mean the death lived in graves and ashes, but I also mean a social death. A kind of death lived whilst still alive. A death lived by the living. A death that is the place between full life and full death. A death that is the living dead. 

The living dead are embodied in the spaces of abandonment. The living dead live unemployed, uneducated, deprived, impoverished, dispersed, broken down. The living dead live across the globe, in our cities here at home, in our terrace housing, our streets, our prisons, in refugee and concentration camps of our making. The living dead is what we created. It is what we created when we decided that not all lives matter. 

George Floyd is a symbol of the living dead of this world, abandoned and brutalised. Somewhere between life and dead. And Syria speaks through this symbol. 


Byline Times is funded by its subscribers. Receive our monthly print edition and help to support fearless, independent journalism.

New to Byline Times? Find out more about us


A new type of newspaper – independent, fearless, outside the system. Fund a better media.

Don’t miss a story…

Our leading investigations include: empire & the culture warBrexit, crony contractsRussian interferencethe Coronavirus pandemicdemocracy in danger, and the crisis in British journalism. We also introduce new voices of colour in Our Lives Matter.

More stories filed under Forgotten Wars

More stories filed under Argument

Almost One Million Children Experiencing Poverty in England Denied Free School Meals

, 4 October 2022
As Mayor of London Sadiq Khan demands universal free school meals for primary school children, Natasha Phillips reports on the impact of the cost of living crisis

The Importance of Learning Lessons from the Pandemic as the Cost of Living Crisis Looms Large

, 4 October 2022
With one Government sitting on its hands and another washing its hands of all responsibility, where does that leave Wales? Leader of Plaid Cymru, Adam Price, writes for the Byline Times

Exposing the Conservative Hedge Fund Scandal: Better Late than Never – Or Too Little Too Late?

, 3 October 2022
As Kwasi Kwarteng faces questions over his attendance at a cocktail party with financiers, Byline Times’ Editor Hardeep Matharu asks why this newspaper’s warnings from three years ago about the influence of hedge fund donors in politics were ignored

More from the Byline Family