Outside the system

How Nigel Farage Twists the Facts About White Boys in Schools to Manufacture Racial Tension

Official data completely contradicts Nigel Farage’s false claim that ethnic minorities are favoured at the expense of white children, reports Nafeez Ahmed

Read Our Monthly Magazine

And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system

Reform UK leader Nigel Farage is currently escalating his bid to scrap the Equality Act – which prohibits discrimination against anyone – by blaming ethnic minorities for the poor educational performance of white working class boys.

However, a Byline Times investigation reveals how he systematically cherry-picks and misrepresents the official data in order to make his case.

Farage used a series of white nationalist tropes in his 7,000-word essay on Substack on 15 June titled ‘Britain is a two tier state – against white people’, in which he called for the repeal of the 2010 Equality Act, describing it as the means by which “anti-Whiteness is institutionalised into every aspect of public life.”

In a video published this week, he stated that white working-class boys were “currently the lowest-performing group in the country’s education system thanks to the Equality Act”, and pledged that Reform UK would “scrap it and return Britain to a meritocracy.” However, the official data Farage cites contradicts both his education claim and the causal argument on which his case for repeal rests.

Farage begins his argument with a truth, which is that white working-class boys are failing in Britain’s schools. However, the same official data that confirms this, also establishes that their underachievement stems from poverty and a decade of austerity cuts, rather than their race. Farage’s explanation – that ethnic minorities are favoured at white boys’ expense by schools, teachers and equality law – is contradicted by every relevant official source he invokes.

Department for Education (DfE) attainment figures, Education Policy Institute (EPI) and Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) research, and government poverty data reviewed by Byline Times demonstrate a consistent picture: working-class children of every ethnicity, girls as well as boys, are held back by poverty, concentrated in deprived communities and entrenched by a decade of funding cuts that landed hardest on the schools that serve them.

And while the severe under-performance of white working class boys cannot be contested, each of Farage’s core claims are contradicted by the official sources he invokes – that white working-class boys are the worst-performing group in British education, that equality law drives preferential treatment for minorities, and that schools condition white children to accept a subordinate status.

ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE

Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.

We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.

Three-quarters of the more than £30 million Reform UK has raised since 2019 came from three multimillionaires whose commercial interests align with a platform of tax cuts for high earners, deregulation and reduced welfare.

Farage’s racial account of school failure performs a precise political function: it directs working-class anger towards minorities and away from a programme whose primary beneficiaries are Reform’s donors.

The case Farage has built for repealing the Equality Act rests on two linked claims. The first is that white working-class boys are the worst-performing group in the British school system. The second is that they are “constantly being told” they hold racial privilege, through classroom teaching and equality rules, despite finishing at the bottom of the attainment tables.

The two claims work as a unit. They construct a group that is at once failed by the system and blamed by it – a portrait of racial victimhood that runs through Reform UK’s messaging. The data behind the portrait shows something else.


‘The Worst-Performing Group‘

Farage’s claim that white working-class boys are the worst-performing group in British education is completely wrong on the official figures.

Take all pupils first. White British pupils scored an average of 44.9 on Attainment 8 – the DfE measure of performance across eight GCSE subjects, marked out of 90 – in 2022/23, against a national average of 46.3. That places them below the average, but above black Caribbean pupils (40.0), pupils of mixed white and black Caribbean heritage (39.1) and the groups at the very bottom.

The lowest-scoring pupils in England are white Gypsy and Roma children, at 20.3, followed by Traveller of Irish Heritage pupils at 26.8. The groups at the foot of the table are white. Farage does not mention them, nor suggest that they might subject to discrimination.

Look only at pupils from low-income families – those eligible for free school meals – and the figures seem to confirm Farage’s case. White British children score 30.9, below disadvantaged Chinese pupils at 60.3, Indian at 48.6, Bangladeshi at 47.7, black African at 44.7, Pakistani at 42.2 and black Caribbean at 35.3. Among children in poverty, white British pupils sit near the bottom of every group – above only white Gypsy, Roma and Irish Traveller children, who score lowest of all.

But only one thing separates this comparison from the previous one: whether better-off white British children are counted. Among all pupils, white British children score 44.9, above black Caribbean children at 40.0. Among poor pupils only, white British score 30.9, below black Caribbean at 35.3. The order reverses because the white British pupils who score well are the ones whose families are better off. Take them out and poor white children sit near the bottom, just as poor children do in every other group. Poverty is what distinguishes the two measures.

The margin that lifts white British pupils above black Caribbean pupils overall comes from the white British majority above the poverty line; remove them, and white British disadvantaged pupils sit near the bottom of every major group. Farage’s cherry-picking conceals the poverty driver and that common working class deprivation afflicting both white and black groups.

The kernel of fact that Farage builds on is real: poor white British boys do badly. He suppresses the fact that white British pupils overall sit above black Caribbean pupils, and that the children scoring lowest of all are Gypsy and Roma.

Don’t miss a story


Poverty and Attainment

Poverty depresses attainment across every group. Nationally, pupils on free school meals scored an average of 34.8 on Attainment 8 in 2022/23, against 49.6 for the rest – a gap of almost 15 points – and within every ethnic group disadvantaged pupils scored below their better-off peers.

A second feature of the data bears on this: the gender gap. Girls scored higher than boys in every ethnic group but one in 2022/23.

Among white British pupils, girls scored 47.1 and boys 42.8. The widest gaps were among black pupils – black Caribbean girls outscored boys by 7.8 points, black African girls by 6.7 – and the only group in which boys did not trail girls was Traveller of Irish Heritage.

Boys lag girls in every community. Working-class girls fail alongside working-class boys. The gender gap – running through every ethnic group and widest among black children – is irreconcilable with institutional bias against white pupils as an explanation.