
Read Our Monthly Magazine
And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system
The Green Party has accused the Labour Party of being compromised over its plans for reforming the water industry by the fact that prominent Labour figures have ties to privatised water firms.
The party has condemned what it calls the “revolving door” between the Labour Government and “failed private water companies and their lobbyists,” in analysis shared with Byline Times.
The links include previous jobs in the industry, roles at public affairs firms with water clients and family interests.
Leader Zack Polanski has now asked whether “this revolving door is why the Government is still negotiating with failed Thames Water instead of using its powers to seek a special administration order and bring the company into temporary public control.”
A special administration order, putting the embattled and heavily indebted water firm under a form of temporary public control, is made by the High Court. Only the Environment Secretary, or Ofwat with her consent, can apply, and the statutory grounds (insolvency or serious breach of duties) must be met. Ministers have argued Thames Water has not met the threshold.
ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE
Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.
We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.
The Green Party leader’s comments come after Thames Water asked creditors for more time to repay a large chunk of its £20bn debt, with the deadline proposed to move from 2027 to March 2028 as it tries to stave off bankruptcy.
Thames Water says creditors representing more than £12bn of secured debt have signed a so-called transaction support agreement, which would push back repayments on high-priority debt due in 2027 to March 2028. Interest would continue to be paid in that time.
The Greens point to a number of current and former Labour figures with ties to the privatised water sector, some involving Thames Water itself. They include:
- Lee Pitcher MP, who used to work for Yorkshire Water. His register of interests records a July 2024 redundancy payment of £5,750 from the company. He also later worked at Jacobs, an engineering consultancy working on water infrastructure, and now chairs the All-Party Parliamentary Water Group. Pitcher was approached for comment.
- Jade Botterill MP was previously a corporate affairs adviser at Yorkshire Water, The i Paper has reported.
- Lord (John) Hutton, the former Labour cabinet minister, will chair Thames Water if the London & Valley Water creditor consortium’s rescue deal goes ahead.
- Melanie Onn MP: the PRCA public affairs register for March–May 2023 listed her as a public affairs practitioner at lobbying outfit Blakeney, which reported Pennon as a paying client. Pennon owns South West Water. Onn returned to Parliament in 2024. We have asked her whether she advised Pennon directly.
- Others mentioned in the Green Party’s analysis include Gregor Poynton MP and Oliver Ryan MP, who worked at lobbying firms which had water industry clients. We have not seen evidence that they personally worked on those accounts.
- Former Labour MPs in paid water industry roles now include Ruth Kelly, who chairs industry lobby group Water UK, which has confirmed she has done so since March 2023. She left Parliament in 2010. A Water UK spokesperson said: “Ruth Kelly assumed her role as Chair of Water UK in March 2023 and her role is a matter of public record.”
- Former Labour MP Ian Pearson is a Thames Water non-executive director and has been since 2014. He also left Parliament in 2010.
- Former Labour cabinet minister Peter Mandelson’s now-collapsed firm Global Counsel listed Water UK as a lobbying client in 2024, according to ITV. The Water UK spokesperson added: “Over the years, Water UK has used a number of firms which provide professional services. As has been publicly disclosed, Global Counsel was one.”
- Andy Burnham’s chief of staff James Purnell was, until June, chief executive of Flint Global, which advises water companies, according to its website. In June, the Liberal Democrats called for PM Burnham to recuse Purnell from any decisions on Thames Water or the wider water industry given his recent professional work “advising the failed water company during his tenure at Flint Global.” A No 10 spokesperson told Byline Times: “Thames Water wasn’t a client of Flint Global during James Purnell’s time at the company,” and added that “to his knowledge” neither were the company’s bondholders. “He doesn’t have any financial interest in Flint Global.” The Downing Street spokesperson said they had seen no evidence that Purnell advised any Thames Water creditor during his time there.
- The Greens also point to several Labour figures with spousal links to the water industry through lobbying firms. Jen Craft MP has reported spouse-held shares worth more than £70,000 in Cavendish, where her husband is a director and which has worked for Southern Water, while Johanna Baxter MP’s husband chairs SEC Newgate, which has listed Anglian Water as a client.
Barry Gardiner MP was paid by Castle Water for speeches in 2024 and 2025. He stresses that Castle Water only supplies businesses, rather than households.
Andy Burnham told The Guardian in June, before becoming Prime Minister, that nationalisation of Thames Water “should be done”. However, there does not appear to be a current clear plan for how this might happen.
Don’t miss a story
‘Deeply Concerning’
Zack Polanski told Byline Times: “The revolving door between the Labour Government and failed water companies is deeply concerning. It raises questions about who the Government is really working for and why it has not yet brought Thames Water into special administration and public control.”
Polanski added that under privatisation, Thames Water has become a “basket case” and has “lurched from one debt crisis to another” while shareholders “continue to fill their pockets”.
The Green leader claims that both Ofwat and the Environment Secretary Angela Eagle “have the power to put the company into special administration tomorrow.”
Instead, he argues, they are being “played” by “vulture capitalist creditors” while bills go up and “our rivers fill with sewage.”
In response to the allegations, a Labour Party spokesperson told Byline Times: “MPs of all parties have a wide range of different experience[s] before coming into politics. Any relevant declarations are made in line with Parliamentary rules.
“All Labour MPs were elected on a pledge to clean up our water industry and take on the rogue water bosses who have put profit before ordinary people for far too long. Labour could not be more united behind our shared mission to deliver greater public ownership of the water industry.”
The spokesperson insisted it would be “wholly wrong” to “draw any false links between any individual politicians’ previous employment experience – or indeed that of their spouses – and their policy positions as elected MPs.”
MPs Respond
A number of the MPs named in the Green Party’s analysis have hit back at the suggestion they are compromised by past or current financial links with the industry.
Steve Race MP was named as one with water industry links. A spokesperson for the Exeter MP said: “Steve worked for [lobbying firm] Lexington for six weeks in 2024 and during that time did not work on behalf of any water companies. He has never held a financial stake in Lexington. Steve has consistently campaigned on water quality and SWW [South West Water] issues, and wants to see much stronger public control over the water system.”
Another was Mary Creagh MP, who told this outlet: “I left Lexington in May 2024. During my time there I did not work on either of the accounts mentioned or any water account. I retain no financial interest in Lexington as a google of my register of interests would reveal.”
Barry Gardiner MP said of his paid speeches for Castle Water: “Unlike Thames Water or Severn Trent, [it] is not a supplier of water, nor a waste water treatment provider to domestic customers. They are a business to business supplier.
“I have given a keynote address to their board meetings on two occasions setting out the impact of the Cunliffe Review on the water sector and speaking about Government plans to exercise greater public control over the sector. The fees paid for these speeches were properly recorded in the Register in the normal way.”
Gardiner added: “With respect to my scrutiny role of the water sector, I would welcome your readers reviewing the parliamentary videos of my cross-questioning the Board of Thames Water and of successive Secretaries of State which can be accessed here.”
“I believe these will provide clear assurance to anyone that my independence of judgement and my ability to scrutinise the industry in forensic detail remain entirely intact.”
Crunch Points Ahead
The Financial Times reported last week that Thames Water’s creditors are preparing a “last and final” offer to take full control of the utility, after ministers rejected their previous offer in June. As part of it, they are asking Ofwat to waive certain regulatory penalties until 2030 in exchange for a one-off £1bn payment into the business. Campaign group We Own It has slammed the proposal which they claim would let the firm “dump sewage freely until 2030”.
A We Own It spokesperson said: “Regardless of where you live, if Thames Water gets permission to ignore the laws to dump sewage, it will set a new low precedent for pollution in rivers and seas throughout England and Wales.
“Andy Burnham promised to reverse 40 years of neoliberalism. He criticised Thatcher’s ideological privatisations. He said that for Thames Water, public ownership is ‘what should be done’. We need all hands on deck right now to stop Thames Water being handed over to US hedge funds.”
Andy Burnham appears to have stepped back from putting Thames Water into special administration for now. In August, he reportedly shelved the plans, and the Government is exploring whether a workable alternative exists to placing the company under administration.
The FT report last week noted the Prime Minister’s allies say he is close to a decision. In the meantime, there are several crunch points, starting with the first court hearing on the proposed debt extension on 27 November. The extension is being done through two court-approved restructuring plans.
The paper also reported that Environment Secretary Angela Eagle is set to amend a water bill, expected in Parliament within weeks, to lift the Thatcher-era cap on the Government holding stakes in water companies, and to lower the legal thresholds for taking water companies into special administration.
On 17 December, creditors are due to vote on the Thames Water plans, and that month regulator Ofwat is also expected to issue its final ruling on proposed major bill hikes at Thames Water. The court is due to decide whether to approve the extension on 13 January. Andy Burnham doesn’t have long.
Got a story? Get in touch in confidence on josiah@bylinetimes.com
holding farage to account #reformUNCOVERED
While most the rest of the media seems to happy to give the handful of Reform MPs undue prominence, Byline Times is committed to tracking the activities of Nigel Farage’s party when actually in power









