Outside the system

‘Calling Reform Racist Doesn’t Work’ Say Unions as They Shift Strategy to Counter Nigel Farage’s Party

Union leaders are changing tack amidst rising support for Nigel Farage’s party among their members

Paul Nowak, general secretary of the TUC, speaking at Congress in Brighton on Sunday. Much of his speech pointed the TUC's arsenal in Reform's direction. Photo: PA Images

Read Our Monthly Magazine

And support our mission to provide fearless stories about and outside the media system

Trade unions are grappling with how to deal with the rise in support of Reform UK among their own members and workers as a whole. 

The rise of the far-right – including Nigel Farage’s party – came up in almost every fringe event and discussion on motions at the Trades Union Congress in Brighton this week. 

In an interview with Byline Times at the annual gathering, the General Secretary of the Usdaw union of shopworkers, Joanne Thomas, said: “We have to take the threat of Reform and the rise of the far right incredibly seriously, because we’ve seen some of the ramifications with regards to hate speech, stirring up communities by driving that agenda of division.”

At a Hope Not Hate panel event on Monday on tackling the challenge, Bakers Union (BFAWU) leader Sarah Woolley said: “There are several things we can do to get into communities and challenge what Reform is putting out there…What we’re doing—certainly in West Yorkshire—is doing picnics, as well as counter-[demonstrations] – bringing everyone together, making it almost a party rather than just an anti-racist demo.

ENJOYING THIS ARTICLE? HELP US TO PRODUCE MORE

Receive the monthly Byline Times newspaper and help to support fearless, independent journalism that breaks stories, shapes the agenda and holds power to account.

We’re not funded by a billionaire oligarch or an offshore hedge-fund. We rely on our readers to fund our journalism. If you like what we do, please subscribe.

“We’re showing that we’re the normal people. They’re the angry people screaming and shouting and threatening—they’re the weirdos.” And she said the union was promoting “music against racism” among other initiatives.

“[We’re] getting back into communities, making being anti-racist fun, not just dealing with misogynistic, horrible, generally white, older men shouting at us.”

But she joined others in agreeing that “calling Reform racist doesn’t work—people already think we use it too much. [But] we are calling them far-right as a movement.” 

Liz Snape, an assistant general secretary at Unison – the UK’s biggest union – added that the ‘easiest option’ is to “stand in a row, shout “far-right fascists,” then we all go home, and we haven’t convinced one single person to think about it or change.”

“In my union, we want to change people’s views. We want to move people, bring people back to where we think they should be. Language is so important, and if you want to engage with somebody, you don’t start with an insult. You start with a gentler message, listen, take people along, talk, then engage.”

She referred to a recent internal Unison survey showing that thirty percent of members are either “Reform supporters or Reform-curious.”

“If we brand them racist and far-right, we’d never talk to them again. I’d like to think as a union that we can engage with every single one of that thirty percent. We’ll never change all of them, but even if we bring that down to twenty percent, we’ll be doing something,” they added.

Don’t miss a story

The senior Unison official added: “If we even suggested to this group they were racist, they’d be distraught.

“We need to find out why people are voting this way, why people are thinking of voting this way, and talk to them initially in a very respectful way. That’s how you win people over, and that’s how we tackle Reform. It’s so important we’re careful about our language.”

Usdaw’s Joanne Thomas told this outlet that unions would be increasingly pointing to Reform’s “anti-jobs agenda.” 

“They’re against the Employment Rights Bill, which will give one of the most significant uplifts to workers that we’ve seen in our lifetime. So to say that they are friends of working people and working class people is incorrect,” Thomas said.

Asked about whether Keir Starmer and his Government had fed some of the anti-migrant narratives picking up pace, she said: “We all have to be stronger. We have to recognise this threat for what it is, and if they start getting more electoral results, we will see catastrophic scenarios play out in councils and communities,” she added.

“Nobody should ever try to out-Reform Reform. So we’ve all got to be mindful of that and careful of that, that we don’t want to hold the conversation in the media even more right wing than it’s already going at the minute. 

“[That’s] something for us all to think about. Whether you’re the leader of the Labour Party, Prime Minister, or any other person – particularly in positions of influence – remember that you shouldn’t be moving that dial towards [the] far-right.”

UPDATE

BBC Bosses Draw Up Plans to Win Over Reform Voters by Changing News and Drama Output

The Director General Tim Davie and other executives discussed altering BBC “story selection” in order to secure the “trust” of supporters of Nigel Farage’s party

Byline Times understands the GMB union has also done a survey of members in its northern regions, again showing high support for Reform. One union figure said GMB was still “reeling” from the results. 

Georgie Laming, campaigns director at Hope Not Hate, said progressives need to stop being “scared of the flag.”

“We won’t use it…[But] we use it when we watch football. Why don’t we use it at other times?…We create a vacuum,” for the far-right to take it, she said.

And she said anti-racists needed to engage with concerns about sexual abuse in different communities: “With some protests around sexual assault at asylum seeker hotels, we [have been] too scared to talk about that. So we allow women to go find someone else who’s speaking to their reality, instead of saying violence against women and girls can happen from anyone, and it’s always unacceptable.” 

Laming added: “We cede that ground to the far-right and don’t address it….We can be proud of our values, but we can’t talk down to peopl